Combat Commander After Action Report – Scenario 117 – Avanti Tridentina, Avanti!

CCE - 117 - Setup

The exclamation point is in the title of the scenario, but it also really applies to this game!

Sometimes Lady Luck shows up looking ravishing, giving you the eye, smiling at you, and then just when you think you might have a chance, she walks off with your hated enemy Jim.

But wait, about an hour later, there she is kind of heading back to you! Giving you that smile again, looking into your eyes, laughing at your jokes and leaning into you.

Until she gets closer and whispers into your ear “Jim’s just better than you” and laughs as she waltzes out the door with him.

But at least the flirting was fun.

Can that be a true experience of a Combat Commander game?

Yes it can!

Welcome to the latest tale from the Combat Commander ladder, that monthly tournament for one of my favourite games out there.

Run by the exceptional Patrick Pence, he of Patrick’s Tactics & Tutorials fame, this is the tournament where you get to play a great game at least once a month. At least, because there is always a game on offer in the Discord if you want a pick-up game at all.

After last month, we’re back in the European Theater of Operations, just outside of Stalingrad, with an encounter between some intrepid Italians with dodgy weapons, and glorious Soviet men…with dodgy weapons.

This month’s opponent was Mark C, a gentleman that I had played back in April 2022 during the ravages of my (I think) only bout with COVID. I was just coming out of it and the game was brutal.

This time, I had no excuse.

Sides were chosen at random and I ended up with the Soviets.

As I mentioned, this month’s scenario takes place outside of Stalingrad after the Soviet attack had shattered the German lines.

A detachment of Italian Alpine troops were surrounded and trying to break out through the frozen wastelands.

CCE - 117 - Setup

(Don’t forget that you can click on a picture to blow it up)

The Soviets (brown – me) set up first, five hexes from the left side of the board, though those three hexes occupied by big Soviet units are also allowable.

The Italians (aqua – Mark) then set up 4 hexes from the right side of the board.

Only a few special rules in this one.

First, there are additional Italian Blackshirt troops and another leader coming in after the third Time trigger.

Secondly, it’s deep winter, so all water hexes are open ground.

Finally, with frozen weapons, all Italian guns break on a roll of doubles (meaning that the use of Sustained Fire could eliminate it in one shot).

Wanna see who was Jim in my above Lady Luck scenario?

Let’s go!

Mark took the first Move order and got his big machine gun into position to menace some of my guys, since none of his startup hexes would do that.

Lt. Visconti and his men moved into the little building, drawing some fire from the Soviet big gun..and promptly all broke.

CCE - 117 - Italian Move 1

That was a fitting start!

Mark tried to Rout them back out of the line of fire, but they refused to budge.

I had another Fire, so with dreams of blowing them all away, the Soviet MMG opened fire again, with another big roll, but not that big if you’re in a building.

The broken squad resisted my big roll by drawing a 12 Time trigger, moving the time along already.

The weapons team for his MMG became suppressed, but didn’t succumb.

Unfortunately, on his morale check, Mark drew a KIA event, which meant they died anyway (you have to eliminate a broken unit and I didn’t have any).

That left Visconti. He only had to roll a 4 or higher to not die.

Rolling a 3, he did go ahead and die.

One big Italian leader out of the way after the first full turn!

Why hello, Lady…you are looking mighty fine tonight.

To keep at least some leadership down there, Lt. Pani ran down the road to get into position to maybe rally these idiots.

CCE - 117 - Italian Move 2

Kovalev kept the heat on, trying to kill that last squad and MMG, but they stood fast, including bringing a sniper down on Kovalev’s head!

He got better really quickly, though.

With the bridge over the frozen stream being worth 4 points (and 2 points for my secret objective), it was time for a Soviet squad to make a dash to take it.

CCE - 117 - Soviet Move 1

They even managed to get out of harm’s way after doing so, joining Kovalev’s fire group.

The Soviet mortar firing up north brought down a Time trigger, but before that Pani and his men had switched with the broken Italian squad and the MMG, putting themselves in the line of fire but removing the broken guys.

Too bad.

Pani then fired on Kovalev’s stack in the building with their puny LMG…and promptly broke it by rolling doubles on his first attack of the day.

Kovalev fired again on Pani…and Pani drew a Time!

It was time (ha!) for the Italian reinforcements to come out.

CCE - 117 - Italian Reinforcements

Mark stacked them along the side, with Aprile leading a sizable contingent, perhaps to move through the forest in the south?

As long as they can get by those Soviet machine guns, anyway.

(ironic spoiler alert)

After firing a couple more times on Pani, it finally happened.

CCE - 117 - Soviet Jammed

I drew a Jammed trigger and broke both my guns!

No, Lady, Jim is a loser! Don’t go off with him!

Taking advantage of that fact, Mark moved the squad with the MMG back into Pani’s space, since they wouldn’t be taking any more fire for a while.

CCE - 117 - Italian Move 3

Not to mention having Aprile and his Blackshirts waltz across the road with the Soviets only being able to curse at them.

With Aprile threatening the two lone militia squads down south, it was time to move Gulkevich to firm them up a bit.

CCE - 117 - Soviet Move 2

On the next turn, they managed to get into the Woods.

With that, it was time to see if the Italians could make a mad dash for the bridge (or at least that’s what I was thinking) as an Italian squad came up to the woods’ edge and discovered that, even without machine guns, Kovalev and his men were pretty dangerous.

CCE - 117 - Italian Move 4

Especially when he draws a 12 Time trigger!

However, it was not all good for the Soviets, as the Italian morale check caused a sniper, and the random hex drawn eliminated all of the broken guns on both sides! Only an LMG for Mark, but my MMG and LMG were toast as well.

As well, it broke Gulkevich!

There she goes, out the door with Jim.

Aprile took that moment to advance on Gulkevich in his weakened state, but Gulkevich’s men were still in fine form, firing away and breaking Aprile (though the rest of the Italians were fine).

Trying to rally Gulkevich, I drew a 12 Time trigger to just suppress him, which would have been fine (I’m leading by 7 points and there would just be one Time left to Sudden Death), but he was vulnerable and I didn’t want to risk it, so I gave up Initiative to reroll.

He rallied just fine.

CCE - 117 - Soviet Move 3

I did back off, though, to give myself some fire lanes and to prevent a massive Italian Ambush attempt.

Then an Italian Blackshirt got it into his head to try and be a hero, making a dash for the bridge.

CCE - 117 - Italian Move 5

And he made it! But took blistering fire and broke when he got there.

In fact, they were so panicked once they got there that a Soviet Rout order moved them back 5 spaces, abandoning the bridge.

Now it was Aprile’s turn to sneak up next to Gulkevich and see what happens.

I had no Fire cards to stop it, and drew no Ambushes.

CCE - 117 - Melee 1

Mark had two!

Gulkevich succumbed to the Italian bayonets but the Soviet squad was fresh.

It was now an Italian 8-5 advantage in strength.

Should be pretty easy, right?

I drew an 8, for a total of 13.

He only needed a 6.

Mark drew a 4, causing Mark to give up the Initiative because he can’t draw that low again, can he?

He drew another 4 and all of Aprile’s heroics went for naught.

Why hello, Beautiful Lady. Welcome back! Did you leave Jim behind?

What’s that? Well hello again, Lady! You still look beautiful.

I did think it was prudent at this stage to take the bridge back, so advanced a squad into the hex, with instructions not to leave it open next time for some random Italian to wander onto it.

CCE - 117 - Bridge

Of course, that left the squad open to Pani’s fire with the MMG, but I had a Recover card waiting!

While trying to break the squad on the bridge, Mark made one of the smartest moves I’ve seen in quite a while.

He Advanced the squad in the woods down in front of the MMG so that they could start adding their firepower to the attack, knowing that his deck was about to run out and he had a Dig In card to put them into foxholes.

Thankfully, I also had a Dig In card, so my squad on the bridge went into foxholes as well.

As Pani kept firing, finally the Italian guns jammed (with a Jammed trigger, not doubles, which I think only happened once in this game).

Of course, that really low-firepower attack is the one that broke my squad on the bridge.

They’re fine under heavy fire, but throw a few potshots at them and they go crazy.

I used my handy Recover card I’d been saving!

And they promptly didn’t rally.

What the fuck?

Lots of discards, lots of terrible firing, and then it happened.

I made what was probably my biggest mistake I’ve made in quite a while, not going with the odds.

CCE - 117 - Bridge 2

Another Italian attack on the bridge and my morale check was a 12 Time!

We’re now at Sudden Death.

If I roll an 8 or below, then I win!

I drew a 10.

Curses!

But I have Initiative, I could reroll.

I have better than 50% odds to draw an 8 or below.

Why not?

No, I decided I wanted to keep Initiative for the future and let the game keep going.

The lone remaining Blackshirt in the woods down south decided to get frisky with the Soviets in the foxholes.

I couldn’t have that, so let them have it.

CCE - 117 - Italian Move 6

My fire attack drew a 9 (which, it turns out, if I had given Mark the Initiative to reroll Sudden Death, wouldn’t have ended the game anyway).

Pani still had some firepower to use on the bridge, but his next attack was pretty piddly.

That didn’t seem to matter, as all of my guys jumped onto the frozen stream hit their heads anyway, getting eliminated.

But the bridge was still mine!

Surely I could get to the next Time trigger still with possession, right?

Pani then made a charge for the forest to help out the Blackshirts (and apparently to suss out whether I had a Fire card, but since it was an Ambush I was saving it).

CCE - 117 - Italian Move 7

But then the other Italian squad made a dash for the bridge and I had to use it.

He survived, but still backed off from the bridge and back into his foxholes.

CCE - 117 - Soviet Move 4

It was time to get somebody else on the bridge to prevent those kinds of dashes, so a handy Militia unit stepped up.

Unable to draw another Fire card (especially an Ambush), sadly my squad in the southern foxholes was promptly stomped on by Pani and his overstacked men.

CCE - 117 - Melee 2

While it cost Mark a point by having to deploy a squad and kill a resulting team, my squad was eliminated and Pani was right next to the bridge.

Next turn, Pani advanced onto the bridge.

While I did have an Ambush finally, it only broke the resulting team.

Mark still had a 9-5 advantage, and then I drew a 3!

So I gave him the Initiative and drew a 10.

Mark gave it right back to me and I drew an 8.

Now it was another 13-8 advantage for me, before Mark’s die roll.

Would history repeat itself?

No, it wouldn’t.

Hey, Lady…I love your breath in my ear…what’s that? No!!!! Don’t go off with Jim!

Yes, the bridge was now in Italian hands and Sudden Death almost certainly was a short time away.

I was hoping Kovalev could lay down some firepower and wipe Pani away, but that didn’t work (though it did kill the broken team, getting me 1 VP).

CCE - 117 - Blaze

I was content to keep doing that to try and dislodge them, until the Lady went out the door with Jim and put a blaze right into my line of sight, keeping me from firing on them anymore.

With that, it was time to try and get up close and personal.

CCE - 117 - Soviet Move 5

A Militia squad moved into the foxholes by the bridge, right next to Pani. Kovalev and his men advanced into the hex next to the bridge on the north side.

I was hoping for one of the many Advance cards that I had been drawing, and maybe an Ambush.

An Italian squad tried to come and bolster Pani’s forces, but they broke in the road right next to the bridge.

A subsequent Prisoners of War event killed them, giving me 2 more points!

But first, Time happened…it was definitely going to end on this one, right?

A 9 or less?

Nope, Mark drew a 10 and we continued.

Just before the next Time happened, Lady Luck looked through the window, arm around Jim, and gave me the finger.

In other words, a Breeze event blew the blaze right onto the bridge, meaning that I could never take control of it even if Sudden Death didn’t happen.

The blaze displaced Pani right into the Russian Militia in the foxholes.

My deck ran out before I could draw anything useful and before the melee actually, though it did take a couple of Initiative passings before finally ending (I drew a 7, passed the Initiative, drew an 11 and Mark passed it back, then a 10 and 8 ended the game).

After hidden objectives were revealed, Mark won the game with 4 VP.

CCE - 117 - End

Here is the final map.

What a wild game.

From the Italians almost being knocked out on Turn 1 to getting back into it because my machine guns broke, but then a really unlucky melee killed the second of his three leaders, to then not being able to hold the bridge myself, I was almost getting whiplash.

Mark is a wonderful opponent and we had a lot of laughs at our respective luck swings.

I thought it was going to end up being a shooting gallery of sorts until both of my main guns broke.

My mortar could hit anything but couldn’t do any damage.

This loss puts me at 34-31 in my ladder career.

I really need a win next month.

December brings us to Normandy, but since we’re running out of individual scenarios, Patrick may mix things up like he did this month (this was supposed to be Stalingrad, but instead it was a Stalingrad scenario from one of the C3i magazines).

If you enjoyed this one, why not join us on the CC Ladder and get some games in with us?

You get to play it monthly and there is always an opportunity for pick-up games. Just ask Tony!

Before we head out, my advice to you is play the odds if you can.

It will most likely come out in your favour.

But maybe not!

See you next month.

Combat Commander Ladder – After Action Reports

To see all of my Ladder After Action Reports since May 2021, go here!

Leave a Reply